I for one am not “sick of you prattling on about how one should never reason from an interest rate change”. This is Substack, your subscribers are looking for the Scott Sumner experience, please keep posting about interest rates much longer than the normal people would find normal.
he is a whateverisian. as in whatever Trump tells him to do he will do and probably fail. That boy been trying to get this job since forever, good luck to all of us when the next crisis hits.
This. Krugman's view is more or less right. Warsh is a lackey. The press, intentionally or unintentionally, is trying to paint him as Tom Hoenig, who, agree or disagree, was a principled hawk. Warsh isn't that. And he's never been that. His pronouncements even during the Obama years weren't principled; they were incoherent. They amounted to declaring that interest rates should be raised because of markets. Not because markets actually anticipated inflation (they didn't), but because Warsh thought they SHOULD. And that's a categorically stupid way to make any kind of policy-- based on "markets, but not actual markets, but how Warsh imagines markets should behave."
"“We can lower interest rates a lot, and in so doing, get 30-year fixed-rate mortgages so they're affordable, so we can get the housing market to get going again,” Warsh, a Fed critic and former member of the central bank’s board of governors, told Fox Business last year.
And Trump was going to allegedly end the endless wars, but I digress, at the moment Trump wants lower rates, Warsh is saying lower rates is a good idea, at the moment I have to think he will implement dovish policies.
Maybe Warsh is smart enough to play whatever monetary policy character he needs for whatever he wants to achieve, a bit like the VP. In his new role, he would probably join the mainstream while staying away from arguing with Trump's stated positions That would be a very good outcome. Better than a principled fighter or a pure syncophant. You have to look at his record as a "politician", deelmaker and manager. There is abundant econonics brainpower within the Fed system end a severe lack of it in the White House. The latter is not a big problem as fiscal policy options have become very limited and all the groups that deserve handouts have already gotten them. But for the 2028 elections there will be very little available to do good old vote buying by the current VP and scorched earth for any Democratic candidate. Not really a concern for the current lot.
Yeah, I'm not worried about the Fed influencing the 2028 election. (Although I am worried about the election for other reasons, such as the risk of Vance winning.)
My uneducated understanding is the Fed is supposed to find the beautiful path of just the right amount of inflation and and just the right amount of unemployment. Given that charter, how much personal choice does the Fed Chair have? Will Warsh try to walk the beautiful path? If not, then isn't he not doing the job Congress assigned?
This is a good point. Given the Fed's mandate, the chair has less power than many people assume. For the most part the Fed follows the market when setting interest rates. it looks like the Fed is setting the market, but if they get too far off course it all blows up.
Brilliant reframe on the NeoFisherian angle. The distinction btween achieving lower rates via expansionary vs contractionary policy is something most ppl miss completley. I worked adjacent to banking regulation for a couple years and the balance sheet reduction piece is kinda tricky without regulatory changes, so it'll be intresting to watch if Warsh can actually pull off what he's promising.
The Fed has a bloated balance sheet from quantitative easing - how can you contract that, that requires selling bonds into a market where nobody's buying.
Scott, isn't Warsh really saying, like Bessent, that when fiscal policy is tuned to produce a higher real growth, the Fed should reward the government with lower interest rates?
Are they both Warstlerian? Trump1's fiscal basket was better than Biden's, and to Warsh the CB should have admitted both. Instead of pretending the Fed is non-partisan, think about lower rates at the margin as a grade the Fed gives for growth: increase energy consumption with increased energy consumption? cut govt employees? deregulate? cut welfare? lower pharma prices? EVEN increased native born employment, bc the unemployment mandate is actually the maximum native workforce (out of the wagon). These things get lower rates.
you silly weak old man... You already admitted Im right when you admitted NGDPLT leaves Congress in charge of inflation. Dude, YOUR ENTIRE THEORY is a secret way to make the Congress turn into Republicans.
Of course it logically follows the Fed should reward GOP style fiscal. Texas outperforms CA on RGDP every quarter.
Look Scott, Trump happened. And you need to reconsider that open borders and free trade WERE GREAT bc Energy consumption growing YOY was over.
Nixon tried price controls.
Carter tried deregulation and a bunch of other bad shit
Reagan came in a moved the factores and imported labor.
And Clinton had to do ALL THAT plus balance the budget to get wage levels growing
Here is the punchline: Factories didnt move where labor was cheaper, they moved bc energy consumption got expensive.
1945-1973 was Economics in beginner mode. We grew energy consumption non stop and the price stayed flat.
We are back in pre-1973. Forever. 10K SMRs drives every mine, processing and port in South, Latin America and Africa. Us miliarty microbases with directed energy weapons. Scott, we have plan.
Don't see anything wrong in reducing the FED balance sheet which expansion was an experiment during GFC. Then the emergency became the rule as it should NOT happen in democracies. Will it be disinflationary? Excellent because still no one has been able to provide a decent explanation for the 2% target.
I favor reducing the Fed balance sheet, but I disagree on the 2% target. I don't favor a 2% target, but if you are going to have one then you damn well better hit it.
I'd guess that Trump believes that a Fed rate cut would automatically cut rates across the yield curve and that this would be an unambiguously good thing.
Do you believe Fed policy had nothing to do with the 2008 crisis? If not, then okay. But it seems to me that if the Fed can indirectly inflate housing costs it can also inflate data centers.
I do think they caused the 2008 crisis, but not by raising interest rates. If your point is that the Fed could hurt the AI sector by causing a recession, then I agree. I just don't view the fact that AI is often financed with debt as the key factor. Interest rates fell during 2008. An equity financed AI sector would also be susceptible to tight money.
My argument is that falling rates would hurt AI too. They’re trying to financially engineer trillion dollar companies that are 3% margin at best. There is no moat except scale, and even that is debatable given what China has accomplished.
Edit: OpenAI is most susceptible but I'm not convinced about the others either.
Agree. Longer-term, Warsh is a little worrisome if there comes a time when AD needs a boost. Seems like the mistakes in magnitudes of stimulus (monetary + fiscal) come from lessons learned after fighting the last war. During the GFC, the last war was inflation (though a long-time ago). And, so they the somewhat undershot stimulus in timing and magnitude. For COVID, they learned during the "last war" that they undershot. Weren't going to make that mistake again, so for fiscal and monetary, pulled out all the stops to goose demand and overshot. Feels like the risk is with Warsh that they may undershoot next time.
From six months ago, a youtube interview via Hoover Institution: "Kevin Warsh On Fixing The Federal Reserve" TL:DR: this gist of it mostly confirms the commentary here about "shrink the balance sheet" & "lower Fed funds" : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVFEcg-RIAk
Yes, exactly. But my PS was only half joking. I really do think his instincts are too hawkish. And pressure from Trump does nudge him in the right direction (unlike with the other Kevin.) Of course it's a pretty weak argument for a Fed chair, and I fear what he'd do under a future Democratic administration.
Hi Professor, been concerned with stubborn 5 year breakevens which have risen as of late. Would argue a hawk is what we need at the moment as nominal gdp looks to be accelerating just as Trump’s vendetta for lower rates takes center stage. How can Warsh manage to please the president by delivering lower rates without first increasing rates to slow the economy and lower the equilibrium rate?
I share your concern. I would not wish to be in Warsh's shoes.
Having said that, the 2.6% breakeven is for the CPI, which implies about 2.3% for the PCE. And the GDP might be a bit distorted by problems measuring AI investment. (Not certain on that.) But in general I agree with you.
I'm not sure if I'm understanding the concepts right. Is this Neo-Fisher idea the thing that they tried in Turkey a few years ago? Am I right in thinking that the Turks ran a policy where they assumed the opposite of the conventional approach, i.e. that lower interest rates would mean lower growth, and vice versa; and that it ended in disaster? Is that the same idea as Neo-Fisher, or a different idea that ends up looking roughly the same in policy terms, or are they not the same at all?
The Turks claimed that reducing interest rates can reduce inflation. That's "reasoning from a price change", and is clearly wrong. Warsh would certainly reject that claim. Instead, Warsh seems to be suggesting that if you do something else to reduce the natural (equilibrium) interest rate, then you can reduce the policy rate at the same time without triggering higher inflation. That's debatable, but not obviously wrong. (I'm skeptical it will work as Warsh hopes in this macro environment.)
The "something else" Warsh has in mind is reducing the Fed balance sheet--reverse QE. That's a contractionary policy that would reduce the natural rate of interest, and might allow for a non-inflationary Fed rate cut.
Another "something else" would be dollar appreciation in the forex market, but of course Trump's opposed to that. Another "something else" would be fiscal austerity, but Trump's opposed to that.
If the Fed lowers its target for short term rates but sells longer dated bonds, wouldn't that just steepen the curve (if anything)? Isn't trump more concerned about the cost of mortgages than short term rates?
I think it depends on how the two policies net out. If the net effect is expansionary, then you are correct. If the net effect is contractionary then even longer-term bond yield may fall (due to slower expected NGDP growth.)
Lowering yields by causing a recession doesn't seem to be the intention. If QT starts to pinch the economy (with Trump still President) does he follow through? Of course not
I had a similar question of whether the Turkey experience was a rejection of the Neo-Fisherian proposition that cutting interest rates would lower inflation. I heard a podcast (Planet Money?) that claimed that Erdogan often heard from small business owners that high interest rates were imposing significant cost burden for them, and that motivated his actions to cut rates.
A related question. Wouldn't reducing the Fed's balance sheet or QT (or reverse QE) raise long-term rates? Or is the policy suggestion that we cut short-term rates (the repo rate) while we also do QT, so as to offset the rise? Is that likely to happen?
I for one am not “sick of you prattling on about how one should never reason from an interest rate change”. This is Substack, your subscribers are looking for the Scott Sumner experience, please keep posting about interest rates much longer than the normal people would find normal.
he is a whateverisian. as in whatever Trump tells him to do he will do and probably fail. That boy been trying to get this job since forever, good luck to all of us when the next crisis hits.
This. Krugman's view is more or less right. Warsh is a lackey. The press, intentionally or unintentionally, is trying to paint him as Tom Hoenig, who, agree or disagree, was a principled hawk. Warsh isn't that. And he's never been that. His pronouncements even during the Obama years weren't principled; they were incoherent. They amounted to declaring that interest rates should be raised because of markets. Not because markets actually anticipated inflation (they didn't), but because Warsh thought they SHOULD. And that's a categorically stupid way to make any kind of policy-- based on "markets, but not actual markets, but how Warsh imagines markets should behave."
His views during the 2010s largely explain why I preferred Chris Waller.
Waller is competent, independent and credible. That pretty much took him out of the running for this post.
Honestly was always shocked Waller managed to get picked for Governor while all of Trump’s other nominees were so far out there
"“We can lower interest rates a lot, and in so doing, get 30-year fixed-rate mortgages so they're affordable, so we can get the housing market to get going again,” Warsh, a Fed critic and former member of the central bank’s board of governors, told Fox Business last year.
And Trump was going to allegedly end the endless wars, but I digress, at the moment Trump wants lower rates, Warsh is saying lower rates is a good idea, at the moment I have to think he will implement dovish policies.
Maybe Warsh is smart enough to play whatever monetary policy character he needs for whatever he wants to achieve, a bit like the VP. In his new role, he would probably join the mainstream while staying away from arguing with Trump's stated positions That would be a very good outcome. Better than a principled fighter or a pure syncophant. You have to look at his record as a "politician", deelmaker and manager. There is abundant econonics brainpower within the Fed system end a severe lack of it in the White House. The latter is not a big problem as fiscal policy options have become very limited and all the groups that deserve handouts have already gotten them. But for the 2028 elections there will be very little available to do good old vote buying by the current VP and scorched earth for any Democratic candidate. Not really a concern for the current lot.
Yeah, I'm not worried about the Fed influencing the 2028 election. (Although I am worried about the election for other reasons, such as the risk of Vance winning.)
Right
My uneducated understanding is the Fed is supposed to find the beautiful path of just the right amount of inflation and and just the right amount of unemployment. Given that charter, how much personal choice does the Fed Chair have? Will Warsh try to walk the beautiful path? If not, then isn't he not doing the job Congress assigned?
This is a good point. Given the Fed's mandate, the chair has less power than many people assume. For the most part the Fed follows the market when setting interest rates. it looks like the Fed is setting the market, but if they get too far off course it all blows up.
Brilliant reframe on the NeoFisherian angle. The distinction btween achieving lower rates via expansionary vs contractionary policy is something most ppl miss completley. I worked adjacent to banking regulation for a couple years and the balance sheet reduction piece is kinda tricky without regulatory changes, so it'll be intresting to watch if Warsh can actually pull off what he's promising.
Can you explain for the lay people here?
The Fed has a bloated balance sheet from quantitative easing - how can you contract that, that requires selling bonds into a market where nobody's buying.
There's always a market for Treasury securities. Just sell at the going market price.
Scott, isn't Warsh really saying, like Bessent, that when fiscal policy is tuned to produce a higher real growth, the Fed should reward the government with lower interest rates?
Are they both Warstlerian? Trump1's fiscal basket was better than Biden's, and to Warsh the CB should have admitted both. Instead of pretending the Fed is non-partisan, think about lower rates at the margin as a grade the Fed gives for growth: increase energy consumption with increased energy consumption? cut govt employees? deregulate? cut welfare? lower pharma prices? EVEN increased native born employment, bc the unemployment mandate is actually the maximum native workforce (out of the wagon). These things get lower rates.
I hope not, as that would be even dumber than the productivity argument. Expansionary fiscal calls for higher rates.
you silly weak old man... You already admitted Im right when you admitted NGDPLT leaves Congress in charge of inflation. Dude, YOUR ENTIRE THEORY is a secret way to make the Congress turn into Republicans.
Of course it logically follows the Fed should reward GOP style fiscal. Texas outperforms CA on RGDP every quarter.
Look Scott, Trump happened. And you need to reconsider that open borders and free trade WERE GREAT bc Energy consumption growing YOY was over.
Nixon tried price controls.
Carter tried deregulation and a bunch of other bad shit
Reagan came in a moved the factores and imported labor.
And Clinton had to do ALL THAT plus balance the budget to get wage levels growing
Here is the punchline: Factories didnt move where labor was cheaper, they moved bc energy consumption got expensive.
1945-1973 was Economics in beginner mode. We grew energy consumption non stop and the price stayed flat.
We are back in pre-1973. Forever. 10K SMRs drives every mine, processing and port in South, Latin America and Africa. Us miliarty microbases with directed energy weapons. Scott, we have plan.
Don't see anything wrong in reducing the FED balance sheet which expansion was an experiment during GFC. Then the emergency became the rule as it should NOT happen in democracies. Will it be disinflationary? Excellent because still no one has been able to provide a decent explanation for the 2% target.
I favor reducing the Fed balance sheet, but I disagree on the 2% target. I don't favor a 2% target, but if you are going to have one then you damn well better hit it.
I'd guess that Trump believes that a Fed rate cut would automatically cut rates across the yield curve and that this would be an unambiguously good thing.
The AI revolution is finance with debt, so rates still matter a lot
Fed policy does not determine the real cost of credit.
Do you believe Fed policy had nothing to do with the 2008 crisis? If not, then okay. But it seems to me that if the Fed can indirectly inflate housing costs it can also inflate data centers.
I do think they caused the 2008 crisis, but not by raising interest rates. If your point is that the Fed could hurt the AI sector by causing a recession, then I agree. I just don't view the fact that AI is often financed with debt as the key factor. Interest rates fell during 2008. An equity financed AI sector would also be susceptible to tight money.
My argument is that falling rates would hurt AI too. They’re trying to financially engineer trillion dollar companies that are 3% margin at best. There is no moat except scale, and even that is debatable given what China has accomplished.
Edit: OpenAI is most susceptible but I'm not convinced about the others either.
Agree. Longer-term, Warsh is a little worrisome if there comes a time when AD needs a boost. Seems like the mistakes in magnitudes of stimulus (monetary + fiscal) come from lessons learned after fighting the last war. During the GFC, the last war was inflation (though a long-time ago). And, so they the somewhat undershot stimulus in timing and magnitude. For COVID, they learned during the "last war" that they undershot. Weren't going to make that mistake again, so for fiscal and monetary, pulled out all the stops to goose demand and overshot. Feels like the risk is with Warsh that they may undershoot next time.
I agree.
From six months ago, a youtube interview via Hoover Institution: "Kevin Warsh On Fixing The Federal Reserve" TL:DR: this gist of it mostly confirms the commentary here about "shrink the balance sheet" & "lower Fed funds" : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVFEcg-RIAk
What is the probability Warsh advocates explicitly for a Nominal GDP Level Targeting framework? Less than 1% ?
So you're telling me there's a chance...
And if he does, what are the odds that the FOMC goes along?
I think the market reaction to Kevin Warsh's nomination was partly due to him not being the other Kevin. It's a relative, not absolute judgment.
Yes, exactly. But my PS was only half joking. I really do think his instincts are too hawkish. And pressure from Trump does nudge him in the right direction (unlike with the other Kevin.) Of course it's a pretty weak argument for a Fed chair, and I fear what he'd do under a future Democratic administration.
Claudia Sahm on how Kevin Warsh sought to shirk and deflect to other authorities at the November 2010 FOMC meeting https://stayathomemacro.substack.com/p/kevin-warsh
Hi Professor, been concerned with stubborn 5 year breakevens which have risen as of late. Would argue a hawk is what we need at the moment as nominal gdp looks to be accelerating just as Trump’s vendetta for lower rates takes center stage. How can Warsh manage to please the president by delivering lower rates without first increasing rates to slow the economy and lower the equilibrium rate?
I share your concern. I would not wish to be in Warsh's shoes.
Having said that, the 2.6% breakeven is for the CPI, which implies about 2.3% for the PCE. And the GDP might be a bit distorted by problems measuring AI investment. (Not certain on that.) But in general I agree with you.
I'm not sure if I'm understanding the concepts right. Is this Neo-Fisher idea the thing that they tried in Turkey a few years ago? Am I right in thinking that the Turks ran a policy where they assumed the opposite of the conventional approach, i.e. that lower interest rates would mean lower growth, and vice versa; and that it ended in disaster? Is that the same idea as Neo-Fisher, or a different idea that ends up looking roughly the same in policy terms, or are they not the same at all?
The Turks claimed that reducing interest rates can reduce inflation. That's "reasoning from a price change", and is clearly wrong. Warsh would certainly reject that claim. Instead, Warsh seems to be suggesting that if you do something else to reduce the natural (equilibrium) interest rate, then you can reduce the policy rate at the same time without triggering higher inflation. That's debatable, but not obviously wrong. (I'm skeptical it will work as Warsh hopes in this macro environment.)
The "something else" Warsh has in mind is reducing the Fed balance sheet--reverse QE. That's a contractionary policy that would reduce the natural rate of interest, and might allow for a non-inflationary Fed rate cut.
Another "something else" would be dollar appreciation in the forex market, but of course Trump's opposed to that. Another "something else" would be fiscal austerity, but Trump's opposed to that.
If the Fed lowers its target for short term rates but sells longer dated bonds, wouldn't that just steepen the curve (if anything)? Isn't trump more concerned about the cost of mortgages than short term rates?
I think it depends on how the two policies net out. If the net effect is expansionary, then you are correct. If the net effect is contractionary then even longer-term bond yield may fall (due to slower expected NGDP growth.)
Lowering yields by causing a recession doesn't seem to be the intention. If QT starts to pinch the economy (with Trump still President) does he follow through? Of course not
I had a similar question of whether the Turkey experience was a rejection of the Neo-Fisherian proposition that cutting interest rates would lower inflation. I heard a podcast (Planet Money?) that claimed that Erdogan often heard from small business owners that high interest rates were imposing significant cost burden for them, and that motivated his actions to cut rates.
A related question. Wouldn't reducing the Fed's balance sheet or QT (or reverse QE) raise long-term rates? Or is the policy suggestion that we cut short-term rates (the repo rate) while we also do QT, so as to offset the rise? Is that likely to happen?
"Or is the policy suggestion that we cut short-term rates (the repo rate) while we also do QT,"
Yes, this seems to be Warsh's view. Long-term rates are harder to predict, as there are effects that work in both directions.